Thursday, March 1, 2012

“Honor your commitments” - The patent gatekeeping problem after antitrust regulators in the United States and the European Union cleared Google’s acquisition of Motorola’s patent pool (Article)

By Norma Cerros, Attorney at law

On February 13, 2012, the Department of Justice’s Antitrust Division (the Division) announced its decision to close its investigations in connection with:


   1. Google Inc.’s (Google) acquisition of 17,000 patents and 6,800 applications (including hundreds of standard essential patents (SEPs) relevant to wireless devices) from Motorola Mobility Holdings Inc. (Motorola);


   2. the acquisitions by Apple Inc., Microsoft Corp. and Research in Motion Ltd. (RIM) of approximately 6,000 patents and patent applications including many SEPs relevant to wireless devices from Nortel Networks Corporation (Nortel); and 

    3. the acquisition by Apple of certain Novell Inc. patents.

As the Division has stated, “all three of the transactions highlight the complex intersection of intellectual property rights and antitrust law and the need to determine the correct balance between the rightful exercise of patent rights and a patent holder’s incentive and ability to harm competition through the anticompetitive use of those rights”.

The clearance by the government was based on the core conclusion that each of these acquisitions was unlikely to substantially lessen competition.

The government reached this conclusion after analyzing the potential ability and incentives of the acquiring firms to use the SEPs that Motorola and Nortel had committed to license on F/RAND terms to industry participants through their participation in standard-setting organizations (SSOs), to prevent or inhibit competition. 

Potential anticompetitive risks identified in this case included: 1) demanding supracompetitive licensing rates from competitors, 2) compelling prospective licensees to grant the SEP holder the right to use the licensee’s differentiating intellectual property, 3) charging licensees the entire portfolio royalty rate when licensing only a small subset of the patent holder’s SEPs in its portfolio, or 4) seeking to prevent or exclude products practicing those SEPs from the market altogether. 

After reviewing the commitments of each of the parties involved in the transactions at issue, the Division concluded that these transactions were “not likely to significantly change existing market dynamics”. However, as per Google’s statement to the IEEE on February 08, 2012, it can be said that the scope of Google’s commitments did not provide the government with the certainty they were expecting. This is mainly because of the conditions Google is imposing in order to agree to grant under RAND terms the patents it acquired from Motorola and to fulfill its commitment not to pursue any injunctive relief in connection with the SEPs it grants, which conditions include, among others:

   a. only in cases of disputes involving future license revenues, and 

   b. only in the event the counterparty forgoes certain defenses such as:

       i. challenging the validity of the patent; 

      ii. pays the full disputed amount into escrow; and 

     iii. agrees to a reciprocal process regarding injunctions and 

     iv. agrees to reciprocal grant-back licenses for Google’s products to the licensee’s Essential     Patent Claims for the same standards.

On the other side of the Atlantic, the European Commission (EC) shared this concern when it issued its decision to clear Google’s acquisition of Motorola’s patent pool on February 13, 2012. EU Commission concluded that “the transaction would not significantly impede effective competition in the European Economic Area (EEA) or any substantial part of it”. The EC made public its concern by narrowing its decision and saying that, notwithstanding the unlikeliness for Google to restrict the use of Android solely to Motorola, which is considered a minor competitor in the EEA, such decision had been reached “without prejudice to potential antitrust problems related to the use of standard essential patents in the market in general”, a concern that undoubtedly motivates the EC to closely follow the strategies of competitors and how they make use of standard essential patents in this market.

Considering Apple’s and Microsoft’s recent actions on both sides of the Atlantic, it can be said that both authorities’ concerns derived from the lack of clarity of Google’s commitments or, put differently, the imposition of several requirements as conditio sine qua non for such commitments, was not far from reality at all.

   a. On February 10, 2012, Apple filed a complaint for declaratory and injunctive relief before the United States District Court in the State of California (and a similar complaint before the EC) alleging that, by suing Apple in Germany, Motorola has breached its obligation to license its cellular standard essential patents on F/RAND terms as per the Patent Licensing Agreement between Motorola and Qualcomm, from which contract Apple is a third party beneficiary;

   b. Despite of Microsoft’s commitment not to seek injunctions against other firms’ products on the basis of standard essential patents, on February 22, 2012 it filed a complaint before the EC against Motorola and Google, alleging Motorola’s attempt to block sales of Windows PCs, Xbox game console and other products, infringing its commitment to license SEPs under F/RAND terms.

It will be interesting to see whether Google, as the new holder of Motorola’s SEPs, will in fact carry out Motorola’s previous commitments and its own commitments after the acquisition, regarding the licensing of such SEPs under F/RAND terms. This question will certainly be answered in the months to come. 

Sources are

95 comments:

  1. Certainly Apple has attracted a lot of the European Commission’s attention in the past few years in the proceedings concerning bubblegum casting

    ReplyDelete
  2. Google and Admeld are direct competitors in the display advertising industry. tubelaunch scam

    ReplyDelete
  3. Really it is shocked to me. Google alone have 17,000 patents and 6800 wireless applications from motorola. Other competitors like microsoft, apple have just 6000 patents and wireless applications from nortel networks. Nortel manual

    ReplyDelete
  4. it can be said that the scope of Google’s commitments did not provide the government with the certainty they were expecting. This is mainly because of the conditions Google is imposing in order to agree to grant under RAND terms the patents it acquired from Motorola and to fulfill its commitment not to pursue any injunctive relief in connection with the SEPs it grants, which conditions include, among others. Thunderstruck 2

    ReplyDelete
  5. My historical interest wants to hear a recording of what the voice might have sounded like, but my self-preservation instinct is reminding me that I do, in fact, want to sleep again ever. Hotel Stralsund

    ReplyDelete
  6. Stephen Holder *fans self*. Trust Linden to get it on with a wholly unsexy serial killer instead of making out with hotpants Holder watch free movies online

    ReplyDelete
  7. Certainly Apple has attracted a lot of the European Commission’s attention in the past few years in the proceedings Espresso Machine Reviews

    ReplyDelete
  8. So glad Holder is trying to end mandatory minimums and surprisingly, it seems like he has a reasonable amount of bipartisan support. Ian Filippini Santa Barbara

    ReplyDelete
  9. Stephen Holder *fans self*. Trust Linden to get it on with a wholly unsexy serial killer instead of making out with hotpants Holder Seo Service

    ReplyDelete
  10. So glad Holder is trying to end mandatory minimums and surprisingly, it seems like he has a reasonable amount of bipartisan support USA cheap baklinks

    ReplyDelete
  11. My historical interest wants to hear a recording of what the voice might have sounded like, but my self-preservation instinct is reminding me that I do, high PR backlinks

    ReplyDelete
  12. So glad Holder is trying to end mandatory minimums and surprisingly, it seems like he has a reasonable amount of bipartisan support high PR backlinks

    ReplyDelete
  13. So glad Holder is trying to end mandatory minimums and surprisingly, it seems like he has a reasonable amount of bipartisan suppor seo barcelona

    ReplyDelete
  14. So glad Holder is trying to end mandatory minimums and surprisingly, it seems like he has a reasonable amount of bipartisan support barcelona seo

    ReplyDelete
  15. My historical interest wants to hear a recording of what the voice might have sounded like, but my self-preservation instinct is reminding me that I do james

    ReplyDelete
  16. Stephen Holder *fans self*. Trust Linden to get it on with a wholly unsexy serial killer instead of making out with hotpants Holder USA backlinks

    ReplyDelete
  17. So glad Holder is trying to end mandatory minimums and surprisingly, it seems like he has a reasonable amount of bipartisan suppor Low OBL Backlinks

    ReplyDelete
  18. I just wanted to come here and tell you that you are doing a wonderful job on making these posts. And you should continue doing so! working tax credit helpline

    ReplyDelete
  19. So glad Holder is trying to end mandatory minimums and surprisingly, it seems like he has a reasonable amount of bipartisan suppor virgin mobile contact

    ReplyDelete
  20. tephen Holder *fans self*. Trust Linden to get it on with a wholly unsexy serial killer instead of making out with hotpants Holder t mobile contact number

    ReplyDelete
  21. I just wanted to come here and tell you that you are doing a wonderful job on making these posts. And you should continue doing so! sky customer service

    ReplyDelete
  22. Stephen Holder *fans self*. Trust Linden to get it on with a wholly unsexy serial killer instead of making out with hotpants Hold samsung customer care

    ReplyDelete
  23. will be interested in more similar topics. i see you got really very useful report of slides, i will be always checking your blog report here. Wine Refrigerator

    ReplyDelete
  24. We are really grateful for your blog post.You will find a lot of approaches after visiting your post.I was exactly searching for. natwest contact number

    ReplyDelete
  25. It is a great website and nice share. I want to thank you. Good job! You guys do a great blog, and have some great contents. Keep up the good work. hmrc

    ReplyDelete
  26. If we push to keep it illegal we then should push to make alcohol illegal, cigarettes illegal, coffee & diet soda, and lastly fast food chains esa contact number

    ReplyDelete
  27. Hi my friend! I wish to say that this post is amazing, nice written and include approximately all important info. edf customer services

    ReplyDelete
  28. i will immediately grab your feed to keep up to date with your online blog. Sounding Out thanks is simply my little ebay contact

    ReplyDelete
  29. tephen Holder *fans self*. Trust Linden to get it on with a wholly unsexy serial killer instead of making out with hotpants Holder dla

    ReplyDelete
  30. tephen Holder *fans self*. Trust Linden to get it on with a wholly
    unsexy serial killer instead of making out with hotpants Holde High PR backlinks

    ReplyDelete
  31. A very awesome blog post. We are really grateful for your blog post. i see you got really very useful topics , i will be always checking your blog thanks. SEO service barcelona

    ReplyDelete
  32. Very interesting to read this article.I would like to thank you for the efforts you had made for writing this awesome article High PR Comments

    ReplyDelete
  33. Whether you are a history buff, hobbyist, or history student, these suggestions for dioramas should get your creative juices flowing Seo service Barcelona

    ReplyDelete
  34. the article is actually the best topic on this registry related issue. I fit in with your conclusions and will eagerly look forward to your next updates. New tyres

    ReplyDelete
  35. Come to your blog, and have opened previous posts to find them well crafted, helpful, and encouraging. Thank you. Part worn tyres Leicester

    ReplyDelete
  36. Thank you so much for providing an experience and take on something I never thought I would find anywhere else buy backlinks

    ReplyDelete
  37. I don’t have the time at the moment to fully read your site but I have bookmarked it and also add your RSS feeds. I will be back in a day or two. thanks for a great site cheap backlinks

    ReplyDelete
  38. A very awesome blog post. We are really grateful for your blog post. i see you got really very useful topics , i will be always checking your blog thanks. seo service in barcelona

    ReplyDelete
  39. hi do you know we can lose weight by simply cut through our food intake? by the way nice design of your website American Taxes system

    ReplyDelete
  40. Step Up Height is is a striking height enhancing key. The item enhances your height as well as will include more advance in your personality fitness tips

    ReplyDelete
  41. hi do you know we can lose weight by simply cut through our food intake? by the way nice design of your website sky contact number

    ReplyDelete
  42. it may not be a taboo topic however usually individuals are not enough to talk on such topics. To the next. Cheers. USA backlinks

    ReplyDelete
  43. I think that you could do with some pics to drive the message home a bit, but other than that, this is great blog Las Vegas Marketing Conference

    ReplyDelete
  44. I don’t have the time at the moment to fully read your site but I have bookmarked it and also add your RSS feeds mail ghost

    ReplyDelete
  45. the other hand would likely love to not agree by incorporating of the reviews that had been manufactured usa backlinks

    ReplyDelete
  46. Under the agreement, Syngenta and Ceres intend to collaborate on small-scale trials as well as larger demonstration-scale field evaluations with mills this season. SEO copmpanies

    ReplyDelete
  47. It is evident from this article that the author who published this article has a pretty good brain. I think that this author needs a bit more applause than he usually gets seo ranking

    ReplyDelete
  48. That publish offers served everyone for an post that we 'm writing. Appreciate it intended for giving everyone another point of view for this subject. cheap seo barcelona

    ReplyDelete
  49. I do think you should consider a little more about individual previous to composing about it. good backlinks

    ReplyDelete
  50. I think that you could do with some pics to drive the message home a bit, but other than that, this is great blog new backlinks strategy

    ReplyDelete
  51. I’m a little lost on everything. Would you suggest starting with a free vinevera skincare

    ReplyDelete
  52. I want to thank you. Good job! You guys do a great blog, and have some great contents. Keep up the good work. Cheap seo service

    ReplyDelete
  53. A couple of million dollars concurrent customers. nevertheless On top of next to lets out income numbers wedding venues manchester

    ReplyDelete
  54. I think that you could do with some pics to drive the message home a bit, but other than that, this is great blog wedding venues manchester

    ReplyDelete
  55. It is easy to see that you are passionate about your writing. If only I had your writing ability I look forward to more updates new backlinks

    ReplyDelete
  56. You will find a lot of approaches after visiting your post. I was exactly searching for. Great work.Thanks for such post and please keep it up. buy Boca Raton links

    ReplyDelete
  57. It is easy to see that you are passionate about your writing. If only I had your writing ability I look forward to more updates safety guidelines newyork

    ReplyDelete
  58. It is easy to see that you are passionate about your writing. If only I had your writing ability I look forward watch fairytail online

    ReplyDelete
  59. which I have been wanting to do for a while. Thanks for this post, it's really useful seo in barcelona

    ReplyDelete
  60. There is no reason why a plumber can’t lead the way and set the example. The electric motor is two to five times more efficient than a diesel engine Seo in Boca raton

    ReplyDelete
  61. I was exactly searching for. Great work.Thanks for such post and please keep it up. Weight loss tips

    ReplyDelete
  62. it has been months for me. Nicely this article that i've been waited for so longcheap seo barcelona
    .

    ReplyDelete
  63. I thought I would leave my first comment. I don’t know what to say except that I have. cheap seo barcelona

    ReplyDelete
  64. I have never visited any site about mad ud af huset like this. I would like to bookmark this link and share to all my friend as well http://phonesheriffapp.com

    ReplyDelete
  65. I was exactly searching for. Great work.Thanks for such post and please keep it http://phonesheriffapp.com

    ReplyDelete
  66. I found so many exciting aspects in your weblog site web page website web page website, especially its discussion seo in barcelona

    ReplyDelete
  67. You'll find polo Ron Lauren inside exclusive array which include particular classes for men, women seo in barcelona

    ReplyDelete
  68. It is easy to see that you are passionate about your writing. If only I had your writing ability seo in barcelona

    ReplyDelete
  69. This really is a wonderful posting, thanks a lot for telling.I am looking forward to discover more fantastic blog posts as this one particular! click here

    ReplyDelete
  70. It is incomprehensible to me now, but in overall, the usefulness and significance is overwhelming boca raton seo

    ReplyDelete
  71. There is no question that instantaneous water heaters are good options to trust in terms of their water heating services. Boca Seo

    ReplyDelete
  72. it is very informative and helpful for me.I admire the valuable information you offer in your articles. roof cleaning

    ReplyDelete
  73. You can invite teachers, parents and children at your elementary school to join roof cleaning

    ReplyDelete
  74. the imposition of several requirements as conditio sine qua non for such commitments, was not far from reality at all mud for sales

    ReplyDelete
  75. The real sin against life is to abuse and destroy beauty, even one's own even more, yellowstone recovery

    ReplyDelete
  76. but learn that alot of people ought to stay on essay to try and add worth in the direction of the authentic CPA Boca

    ReplyDelete
  77. Unfortunately, some of Ann's accounts don't jibe with other records from the Revolutionary War period, calling many of them into question. six degree flow review

    ReplyDelete
  78. The very software is normally highly consumer-helpful plus simple and easy in order to implement best online stock trading

    ReplyDelete
  79. I found so many exciting aspects in your weblog site web page website web page website, especially its discussion best online stock trading

    ReplyDelete
  80. We are moderately limited hiring that hairdressing sort along with additionally Allow me to discover person's recommendations with this kind Ungagged

    ReplyDelete
  81. I am writing a paper of the qualities of a great leader and george washington in particular. Money Making Conference

    ReplyDelete
  82. I was exactly searching for. Great work.Thanks for such post and please keep it up money lender

    ReplyDelete
  83. i am writing a paper of the qualities of a great leader and george washington in particular. seo barcelona

    ReplyDelete
  84. I would like to bookmark this link and share to all my friend as well seo barcelona

    ReplyDelete
  85. I am hopeful the same best work from you as well. Actually your creative writing abilities has motivated me boca seo

    ReplyDelete
  86. I just want to let you know that I just check out your site and I find it very interesting and informative. Promotif

    ReplyDelete
  87. I check your blog everyday and try to learn something from your blog Vegas Conference

    ReplyDelete
  88. It is such an important topic and ignored by so many, even professionals. professionals. I thank you to help making people more aware of possible issues. Ungagged

    ReplyDelete
  89. I will post a link to this page on my blog. I am sure my visitors will locate that extremely useful seo in barcelona

    ReplyDelete
  90. it is very informative and helpful for me.I admire the valuable information you offer in your articles. Thanks for posting it easy boca movers

    ReplyDelete
  91. I had been on the front lines of vaccine education and awareness, continually partnering with families to protect children. And out of nowhere, measles arrived. spain seo

    ReplyDelete
  92. it is very informative and helpful for me.I admire the valuable information you offer in your articles. SEO in cheap

    ReplyDelete
  93. I don’t actually comment and don’t like to spend time in typing the comment. vine vera seo spain

    ReplyDelete
  94. I’ve looking for and excited to read all the posts. I am looking forward to another great article from you.hack clash of clans

    ReplyDelete
  95. You’ve make me re-live those precious moments with this amazing article and I would like to thank you for that best backlinks usa

    ReplyDelete